Hi Jenny,
Switch to powdered herbs. If I search "lakewood, OH herbal", google.nl shows a map with 7 herb shops. Two are within walking distance:
urbanherbsonline.com
1979 West 25th Street, Cleveland, OH,
+1 216-241-5444
and
Culinary Herbs & Products
22289 Bartlett Drive, Cleveland, OH,
+1 440-333-4525
I don't like the price of fenugreek at urbanherbsonline.com
I pay about a dollar for ten ounces at the oriental supermarket. They have herbs in plastic bags, instead of in nice jars. I get fenugreek and fennel from there. Is there a business like that in your area? It doesn't need to be as posh as http://www.asiantowncenter.com/food_market.html
Hops and goat's rue are about $ 10 for three months, and I know they're the same price in herb shops in NYC and New England. Hops is sometimes a better deal in home brewers' supply shops:
Rozi's Wine House
14900 Detroit Ave., Lakewood, OH,
+1 216-221-1119 · rozis.com
Their price is nice: http://www.rozis.com/store/product.php?productid=17816&page=1 $ 2.79, only it doesn't say for exactly how many ounces.
My most expensive supplement is maca flour, $ 20 for three months.
Good luck